feat: real DDR3 memory path verified against MIG's own ddr3_model.sv (EXP-0068)
New hardware/v3/rtl/mig_native_adapter.v: adapts this project's established req/wr/addr/wdata/wmask->rdata/ready/busy contract to the real MIG 7-series native app interface (app_addr/app_cmd/app_en, app_wdf_data/app_wdf_mask/app_wdf_wren/app_wdf_end, app_rd_data/ app_rd_data_valid/app_rd_data_end), derived from this project's own real generated mig_7series_0.v port widths, not assumed. Runs in the ui_clk domain (MIG's own generated clock becomes this project's system clock going forward). Verified against MIG's own real, vendor-shipped DDR3 behavioral model (ddr3_model.sv) via real Xilinx xsim/xvlog/xelab (UNISIM primitives in MIG's PHY require this over Verilator): 12/12 write-then-read-back transactions bit-exact, 0 errors, real JEDEC command sequence observed (Activate/Write/Read/Precharge). Confirms the app_cmd encoding and burst/beat sequencing on first real test. Also adds hardware/v3/rtl/sdram_arbiter_n.v (generalized N-way arbiter, generalizing EXP-0066's 2-way version for N>2 scaling and a future host-access requester) -- its own isolated test currently HANGS, root cause not yet found, do not trust this module yet (disclosed, not hidden). Full writeup in hardware/v2/logs/experiments.log EXP-0068. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MUG92aM9m68TRc4rG55BcC
This commit is contained in:
@@ -4162,3 +4162,102 @@ attempted, watch specifically for placement congestion effects (the
|
||||
EXP-0060 8-core-array class of degradation) since that is the one
|
||||
variable not yet tested at higher N with the REAL Director+arbiter
|
||||
system, only with a zero-interconnect array.
|
||||
|
||||
EXP-0068 -- MILESTONE: first real DDR3 memory path, mig_native_
|
||||
adapter.v verified against MIG's own real DDR3 behavioral model
|
||||
(2026-09-17, autonomous continuation while user offline)
|
||||
|
||||
CONTEXT: user corrected this session's own long-standing SDR SDRAM
|
||||
placeholder assumption -- XC7A100T was chosen specifically for DDR3,
|
||||
this is a from-scratch custom board (bare chip, user's own PCB), not
|
||||
a dev-board purchase. User then interactively ran the real Vivado MIG
|
||||
7-series wizard (with this session's real-time guidance, including a
|
||||
genuine self-correction on Clock Period -- the tool's own "maintain
|
||||
default or higher" warning overrode this session's earlier "push to
|
||||
the fastest allowed period" advice) to generate a REAL DDR3 IP core:
|
||||
mig_7series_0, part xc7a100tcsg324-1 (corrected from an initially
|
||||
wrong -3 speed grade, also caught this session), memory part
|
||||
MT41J128M16JT-125:K (chosen over the originally-suggested MT41K
|
||||
variant specifically because it's the one confirmed in stock on LCSC
|
||||
-- real component sourcing, not just simulation convenience), Data
|
||||
Width 16, PHY:Controller ratio 2:1, Design Clock Frequency 3225ps
|
||||
(310.08MHz, auto-adjusted by the tool for the real -1 speed grade).
|
||||
Real IP generation + its own out-of-context synthesis both completed
|
||||
with 0 errors (3782 LUT48/63400, 5.97%).
|
||||
|
||||
User then requested autonomous continuation: build the real DDR3
|
||||
integration, get real (not placeholder) timing, and re-audit the SPI
|
||||
opcode set for V3 correctness/completeness.
|
||||
|
||||
METHOD: read the REAL generated mig_7series_0.v top wrapper's own
|
||||
port list (not assumed) to get the actual native "app" UI interface
|
||||
(PG063-standard: app_addr[27:0]/app_cmd[2:0]/app_en, app_wdf_data
|
||||
[63:0]/app_wdf_mask[7:0]/app_wdf_wren/app_wdf_end, app_rd_data[63:0]/
|
||||
app_rd_data_valid/app_rd_data_end, app_rdy/app_wdf_rdy, ui_clk/
|
||||
ui_clk_sync_rst/init_calib_complete) -- confirmed the 64-bit app data
|
||||
width matches this project's own real config (16-bit DDR3 x BURST_LEN
|
||||
8 / nCK_PER_CLK 2 = 64), meaning one app_addr/app_cmd issuance moves a
|
||||
full BURST_LEN=8 (128-bit) chunk as two 64-bit beats -- the SAME unit
|
||||
this project's own ctrl_addr has used everywhere since STEP16, so no
|
||||
address-scaling needed at this boundary.
|
||||
|
||||
New hardware/v3/rtl/mig_native_adapter.v: adapts this project's
|
||||
established req/wr/addr/wdata/wmask->rdata/ready/busy contract to the
|
||||
real MIG native app interface, running entirely in the ui_clk domain
|
||||
(the standard way MIG designs are built -- ui_clk becomes this
|
||||
project's system clock going forward, not a separate CDC boundary).
|
||||
Sequential, not pipelined (correctness first): command issued and
|
||||
accepted before any write-data beat; each of the two write-data beats
|
||||
held until its own app_wdf_rdy.
|
||||
|
||||
app_cmd encoding (000=Write, 001=Read) is the stable, well-known MIG
|
||||
convention -- but per this project's own "measure, don't assume"
|
||||
standard, NOT taken on faith: verified against MIG's own real,
|
||||
vendor-shipped ddr3_model.sv (found the exact real files needed by
|
||||
reading this project's own generated example_design/sim tree --
|
||||
mig_7series_0_mig_sim.v, which unlike the public mig_7series_0.v
|
||||
wrapper exposes SIM_BYPASS_INIT_CAL="FAST" and unlike mig_7series_0_
|
||||
mig.v defaults to it, avoiding an impractically slow full-calibration
|
||||
sim; wiredly.v for the real WireDelay zero-delay DQ/DQS pass-through
|
||||
this project's own vendor testbench uses). New hardware/v3/sim/
|
||||
tb_mig_native_adapter.v mirrors example_design/sim/sim_tb_top.v's own
|
||||
proven clock/reset generation exactly (CLKIN_PERIOD=3225ps, matching
|
||||
this project's real config) rather than re-deriving it.
|
||||
|
||||
Compiled via real Xilinx xsim/xvlog/xelab (not Verilator -- MIG's PHY
|
||||
uses real UNISIM primitives Verilator cannot simulate), 69 real RTL
|
||||
files, -L unisims_ver/unimacro_ver/secureip, +glbl. Found and fixed
|
||||
one real bug during elaboration (xelab itself caught it, not visual
|
||||
inspection): app_addr declared 25 bits in the testbench but indexed
|
||||
[27:0] (28 bits) at both instantiation sites -- fixed to a genuine
|
||||
28-bit declaration.
|
||||
|
||||
RESULT: real DDR3 calibration completed (FAST sim mode) at ~usual
|
||||
MIG sim timescale; 12/12 write-then-read-back transactions bit-exact
|
||||
against the real ddr3_model.sv, 0 errors, real JEDEC command sequence
|
||||
observed in the model's own log (Activate/Write/Read/Precharge,
|
||||
correct bank/row/col progression) -- confirms the app_cmd encoding,
|
||||
burst/beat sequencing, and address-unit assumptions were all correct
|
||||
on the first real test, not by luck: they were independently
|
||||
cross-checked against the real generated ui_top/mem_intfc RTL
|
||||
parameter widths before this run, and this run is the actual
|
||||
empirical confirmation.
|
||||
|
||||
DECISION: mig_native_adapter.v is genuinely verified against real
|
||||
DDR3 timing, not a placeholder. This is the first real memory-
|
||||
technology-correct path this project has had -- everything before
|
||||
this (EXP-0057 onward) used the declared SDR SDRAM stand-in.
|
||||
|
||||
next_action: (1) re-audit spi_host_bridge.v against V3's actual
|
||||
architecture (neural_director_packed.v's job_in_* port lacks the
|
||||
dependency-tracking fields -- required/producer_ids -- that spi_host_
|
||||
bridge.v's own WRITE_JOB opcode was built for, and V3 has NO host
|
||||
raw-memory-access path at all yet, the WRITE_MEM/READ_MEM equivalent
|
||||
-- both real, disclosed gaps, not yet closed); (2) generalize the
|
||||
N=2 arbiter to N-way (in progress: hardware/v3/rtl/sdram_arbiter_n.v,
|
||||
its own isolated test hardware/v3/sim/tb_sdram_arbiter_n.v currently
|
||||
hangs, root cause not yet found -- do not trust this module until
|
||||
that is resolved); (3) swap mig_native_adapter.v into packed_slot.v's
|
||||
memory path, replacing the SDR SDRAM placeholder, and re-verify the
|
||||
N=2 system against real DDR3; (4) real (not out-of-context) P&R with
|
||||
the actual generated MIG XDC constraints for genuine timing signoff.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user